Market Review: Completed
On 16 July 2014, the Reliability Panel (Panel) published its final report for the reliability standard and reliability settings review 2014. The final report contains the Panel’s decision on the reliability standard, and recommendations on the reliability settings (that is, the market price cap, cumulative price threshold and market floor price), that are to apply for the National Electricity Market from 1 July 2016.
Panel’s final decision and recommendations
Reliability standard and reliability settings
The Panel’s decision with respect to the reliability standard and recommendations with respect to the reliability settings are as follows:
- Reliability standard: The Panel has determined to retain the current form and level of the reliability standard to apply from 1 July 2016. That is:
- the reliability standard will remain in the form of an output-based measure expressed in terms of the maximum permissible unserved energy; and
- the level of the reliability standard will remain at 0.002 per cent of the annual energy consumption for the associated NEM region, or regions, per financial year.
- Market price cap: The Panel’s recommendation is that no change be made to the real value of the MPC to apply from 1 July 2016. The MPC should continue to be indexed by the Consumer Price Index (CPI), annually.
- Cumulative price threshold: The Panel’s recommendation is that no change be made to the real value of the CPT to apply from 1 July 2016. The CPT should continue to be indexed by the CPI, annually.
- Market floor price: The Panel’s recommendation is that no change be made to the current value of the MFP to apply from 1 July 2016. In addition, the MFP should continue to be set in nominal terms (that is, the MFP will not be indexed annually).
Recommended future investigations
The Panel also recommends that the AEMC or the Panel (as appropriate) complete the following investigations prior to the next reliability standard and settings review which is due to commence in 2017:
- Review of Indexation of the reliability settings: The Panel recommends a review to consider whether the current indexation process is operating as effectively as possible, and whether CPI remains the most suitable index to use. This review should occur within two years.
- Review of the form of the CPT: The Panel recommends a review to explore whether the current CPT mechanism is suitable and effective as a risk management mechanism, and whether it is appropriate to retain the link between MPC and CPT.
- Value of customer reliability (VCR): The Panel recommends the development of a methodology to derive an appropriate estimate of VCR to help inform the identification of an efficient reliability standard. This review should be carried out in consultation with stakeholders and have regard to any VCR values delivered by AEMO as part of its national VCR review.
- Methodology for future reliability standard and reliability settings reviews: The Panel recommends a review to develop a methodology for undertaking future reliability standard and reliability settings reviews, including consideration of how the outcomes of any market modelling could be treated.
In developing its decision on the reliability standard and recommendations on the reliability settings, the Panel has sought to balance benefits of stability and predictability of the NEM’s reliability framework against the potential for various changes to the reliability standard and the reliability settings, to further promote efficiency in the NEM.
The Panel considers that its decision and recommendations are likely to maintain certainty and help to continue to deliver efficient operational and investment decisions in the long term. This is in the long term interests of consumers as it promotes an appropriate balance between prices and reliability of supply of electricity.
Under the National Electricity Rules (NER), the Panel is required to review the reliability standard and reliability settings once every four years.This regular review allows the Panel to consider whether changes should be made to ensure these mechanisms continue to meet the requirements of the market, market participants and consumers.
Following completion of the review, the Panel may set a new reliability standard, while any recommended changes to the reliability settings would be submitted to the AEMC for consideration as a rule change request.
Purpose of the review
The purpose of the 2014 review was to:
- determine whether the existing reliability standard is appropriate for the current market arrangements;
- determine the form and level of the reliability standard that should apply from 1 July 2016;
- recommend the appropriate reliability settings to apply in the NEM from 1 July 2016 to achieve the reliability standard chosen; and
- propose processes for implementing any changes arising from the review
On 9 May 2013, the Panel published an issues paper for the review. Twelve stakeholder submissions were received in response to the issues paper.
On 13 March 2014, the Panel published its draft report for public consultation. The draft report contained the Panel's draft decision on the reliability standard, and draft recommendations on the reliability settings, that were proposed to apply from 1 July 2016. Eight submissions were received in response to the draft report.
Modelling by ROAM Consulting
To assist the Panel in its review, ROAM Consulting (ROAM) were engaged to undertake market modelling. ROAM’s draft modelling report was published for public consultation on 16 December 2013. Five submissions were received. ROAM’s draft findings were also presented at a public forum on 4 December 2013.
The Panel published ROAM’s final modelling report on 16 July 2014, along with the Panel’s final report for this review.
Reliability Panel documents
Submissions on ROAM Draft Report
Reliability Panel documents
|Information Sheet - ROAM draft report||Reliability Panel Presentation - 4 December 2013|
|ROAM Draft Report||ROAM Presentation - 4 December 2013|
|Reliability Panel Draft Report||Information Sheet – Reliability Panel Draft Report|
Late submissions on Reliability Panel Draft report
|AGL Energy - received 11 April 2014||Alinta Energy- received 11 April 2014|
|Origin Energy - received 11 April 2014|
Submissions on Reliability Panel Draft Report
Supplementary submissions on Reliability Panel Draft Report
Submissions on Issues Paper
|AGL Energy||Alinta Energy|
|Energy Supply Association of Australia||GDF Suez Australian Energy|
|Macquarie Generation||Major Energy Users|
|National Generators Forum||Origin Energy|
|St Kitts Associates||Stanwell Corporation Limited|